My Mind’s Broadway

Welcome to a vibrant recap of my unforgettable debut experience attending Broadway shows in New York City! Here, you’ll discover in-depth reviews and personal insights on four spectacular productions: Les Misérables, Phantom of the Opera, Aladdin, and Rock of Ages, along with essential tips for your own Broadway adventure.

The magic of Broadway had always been a distant dream, a fervent wish I’d harbored for years. So imagine my absolute delight when Mr. Wishes orchestrated a spectacular surprise trip to New York City at the end of August. For about six months, I had been persistently (some might say relentlessly!) asking him to take me to see the iconic Les Misérables on Broadway. Whether it was his boundless love for me, or perhaps just a desire for some peace and quiet, he finally conceded. Over a delightful dinner one evening, he could no longer contain the secret. He revealed that plane tickets were booked, a hotel secured, and, most incredibly, we would be seeing not only Les Miz the following weekend, but also two other shows I had been longing to experience: Disney’s Aladdin and Andrew Lloyd Webber’s timeless masterpiece, The Phantom of the Opera. Truly, the “Best Husband Ever” award belongs unequivocally to him! My excitement was palpable; I immediately began packing that very night, a full week in advance, eager for the theatrical marvels that awaited.

If you’re contemplating a trip to the Great White Way and feeling overwhelmed by the sheer number of incredible productions, allow me to share my recent experiences to help guide your choices. My weekend adventure encompassed a diverse range of theatrical delights, from a fresh, vibrant spectacle perfect for all ages (Aladdin) to timeless classics that continue to captivate audiences (The Phantom of the Opera and Les Misérables), and even a high-energy, fun-filled rock celebration (Rock of Ages). I’ll provide detailed thoughts and enthusiastic recommendations for each. While I wholeheartedly suggest experiencing all four of these shows, if your time in NYC is limited to just one performance, Les Misérables stands out as an absolute must-see. Below, you’ll find my reviews, presented in a uniquely personal order.

Les Misérables: A Dream Realized on Broadway

There’s no need to save the absolute best for last. Breaking from tradition, I’m diving straight into my top recommendation because, well, it’s my blog, and I get to make the rules! Les Misérables isn’t just a musical; it’s a global phenomenon, proudly holding the title of the world’s longest-running musical, and for profoundly good reasons. Witnessing this epic saga unfold on a Broadway stage was nothing short of a dream come true, a moment etched forever in my memory. My deep affection for this particular story didn’t fully blossom until I acquired the 25th-anniversary Blu-ray disc of the 2010 performance. From that moment, I was utterly captivated. I honestly hadn’t anticipated falling so deeply in love with the intricate storyline and magnificent score, but it won me over with breathtaking speed. The live Broadway performance not only met but soared past all my already sky-high expectations. In fact, its impact was so profound that I tried, unsuccessfully, to convince my husband to take me to see it again the very next day! That alone speaks volumes about its unparalleled brilliance.

The production was a masterclass in emotional storytelling, featuring truly beautiful singing and astounding acting that collectively created an immersive experience. Ramin Karimloo, portraying the central figure of Jean Valjean, truly commanded the stage, delivering a performance that transcended mere acting. His vocal talent is simply extraordinary, his acting deeply moving, and beyond his immense stage presence, he is genuinely a kind person. The entire ensemble cast, from the smallest roles to the lead, performs with such passion and precision that they will undoubtedly leave you spellbound. If my words haven’t yet convinced you to secure tickets for this legendary show, I truly don’t know what will. It’s an unparalleled journey into the human spirit, a testament to resilience, love, and sacrifice that resonates long after the final curtain falls.

The Phantom of the Opera: A Timeless Romance on Stage

For as long as I can remember, The Phantom of the Opera has held an unparalleled position as my number one theatrical love. This masterpiece by Andrew Lloyd Webber occupies a truly special place in my heart, deeply intertwined with significant personal moments. One such cherished memory is from my wedding, where the bridal party gracefully walked down the aisle to the enchanting melody of “All I Ask of You,” beautifully rendered by a talented string quartet from the Rochester Philharmonic Orchestra (RPO). As I stood by the grand sanctuary doors, poised for my own entrance, the sheer beauty of that music filling the space brought tears to my eyes even before I took my first step down the aisle. That particular song possesses an incredible power over me, evoking profound emotion every single time I hear it. Prior to my wedding, I would often listen to it on my iPod during my runs, vividly imagining how it would sound, live and resonant, during our ceremony. The reality was even more breathtaking than my dreams. Since then, “All I Ask of You” has become “our” song, a shared melody between Mr. Wishes and me. He even surprised me one Christmas with a Phantom of the Opera ornament that, with a simple touch, plays our special tune, a cherished keepsake I proudly display all year long.

But enough about my personal connection; let’s talk about the show itself – it was absolutely phenomenal. I must express my regret that the incredibly talented Sierra Boggess is no longer gracing the stage as Christine; I am eternally grateful that I had the privilege of witnessing her captivating performance before her departure. Norm Lewis took on the complex role of the Phantom, and even as a self-professed “Phantom snob,” I was profoundly impressed by his commanding presence and vocal prowess. He is, without a doubt, a legitimate talent. I own the 25th-anniversary Blu-ray disc of the Royal Albert Hall performance from 2011 and am amazed it hasn’t worn out from repeated viewings. Seeing Phantom live on Broadway not only met but spectacularly exceeded my already high expectations. The vocal performances were as rich and powerful in person as I had always hoped they would be, perfectly conveying the raw emotion of the story. There truly is nothing more beautiful than the music of The Phantom of the Opera. NOTHING. It’s an experience of sublime tragedy, passionate romance, and unforgettable melodies that continue to enchant audiences worldwide.

Aladdin: A Dazzling Spectacle for All Ages

My decision to experience Disney’s Aladdin on Broadway was solidified after watching the Tony Awards in June. I was instantly captivated and utterly convinced when I witnessed the electrifying performance of James Monroe Iglehart, who masterfully portrays the Genie, during his rendition of “Friend Like Me.” I would confidently tell anyone to see this show for that song alone; it is undeniably *that* good and *that* spectacularly entertaining. The entire musical bursts with vibrant colors, intricate costumes, and infectious energy, making it an absolute delight for children. However, to consider it solely a children’s show would be a disservice, as I firmly believe there’s an abundance of thrilling action, breathtakingly fancy sets, generous doses of clever comedy, and spectacular dance numbers to enchant adults just as much. It’s a truly dynamic production that leaves a lasting impression, and I wholeheartedly recommend it.

Good luck resisting the irresistible urge to leap out of your seat and dance along with the vibrant cast – or perhaps that’s just a personal challenge of mine! (My husband, ever the pragmatist, did have to remind me beforehand that this was, in fact, not a sing-along production). The set design is nothing short of spectacular, particularly during the iconic magic carpet sequence. Here, Aladdin (played by Adam Jacobs) and Princess Jasmine (Courtney Reed) share a tender, romantic moment beneath a twinkling, starry sky, creating an atmosphere of pure enchantment. The stagecraft involved in making that carpet truly fly is absolutely awesome and genuinely mind-boggling, adding an extra layer of wonder to an already magical show. Every element, from the dazzling visuals to the unforgettable musical numbers, contributes to an experience that is both heartwarming and visually stunning, making Aladdin a must-see for anyone seeking pure theatrical joy on Broadway.

Rock of Ages: An Electrifying 80s Rock Extravaganza

My anticipation for Rock of Ages was primarily fueled by my deep-seated love for 80s music. And yes, I’m a die-hard fan of that era’s rock anthems, and I’m absolutely not ashamed to admit it! Growing up with this iconic sound (albeit a decade or so after its peak), I was incredibly excited at the prospect of hearing classics like “Don’t Stop Believin’,” “Here I Go Again,” and “Nothing But a Good Time” performed live on stage. This show distinguishes itself with its highly engaging and interactive approach, making the audience an integral part of the experience. Any show that encourages me to sing along instantly wins me over. Attending Rock of Ages felt less like a traditional theater experience and more like being immersed in an exhilarating, fun-filled rock and roll party. It’s a guarantee that you’ll be smiling, tapping your feet, and singing along for the entire duration of the show.

The Helen Hayes Theater, where the show was performed, is quite intimate, with only around 600 seats. This smaller venue size is actually a huge advantage, ensuring that there genuinely isn’t a bad seat in the house. I was fortunate enough to be seated in the very front row, directly in front of a speaker – an experience so close to the action that I’m surprised I didn’t suffer any hearing loss! The show itself is hilariously entertaining, brimming with witty dialogue and high-energy performances. However, it’s important for potential attendees, especially those considering bringing children, to be aware of the content. My more conservative side feels compelled to mention that the show contains some strong language and mature themes that may not be appropriate for younger audiences. As always, my advice for any Broadway show is to conduct a little research beforehand. Checking basic plot summaries and content warnings will help you know exactly what to expect and ensure it aligns with your preferences and those of your family.

One of the most thrilling and unique aspects of attending Broadway shows is the post-performance ritual of visiting the Stage Door of the theater. (It’s always a good idea to research the exact location beforehand, as they can sometimes be a bit tucked away). This is where many of the talented actors often emerge to greet their fans, sign Playbills (the official program), and occasionally even pose for photographs. For me, this was a non-negotiable part of my NYC trip. My appreciation wasn’t just for the incredible productions themselves, but a significant portion of the magic lay in the exceptional performers bringing those stories to life. I already recognized many of the actors, which made the entire experience even more profoundly special and personal. Specifically, some of my absolute favorite actors and singers were starring in two of the shows we had tickets for: Ramin Karimloo, then playing the role of Jean Valjean in Les Misérables, and Sierra Boggess, who was portraying Christine in Phantom of the Opera. Meeting them at the stage door was a genuine dream come true, an interaction I’ll cherish forever. Norm Lewis, Ramin Karimloo, James Monroe Iglehart, and Adam Jacobs were all remarkably kind, friendly, and patient at the stage door, generously dedicating time to interact with their enthusiastic fans. This intimate moment of connection with the artists truly elevates the Broadway experience from simply watching a show to becoming a part of its living, breathing legacy.

To top off an already incredible journey, I received an exclusive, special invitation to go backstage at Les Miz. Even months later, I am still in utter disbelief at how incredibly fortunate I was to have such an extraordinary opportunity. To travel all the way to New York City to see the Broadway show I had so desperately longed for, and then to be granted a peek behind the curtain – the very fabric of its creation – was absolutely mind-blowing. The experience of seeing the intricate workings, the sets up close, and the bustling energy of a major Broadway production from a perspective few ever witness, remains a vivid and deeply cherished memory.

---

Essential Broadway Etiquette & Ticket Tips for Your NYC Adventure

Having now experienced the magic of Broadway firsthand, and perhaps earning the title of a temporary “Broadway expert,” I’m eager to share some invaluable tips. These insights are designed to enhance your trip to New York City, particularly if your itinerary includes immersing yourself in the world of Broadway shows:

1. Prioritize Punctuality: Arrive Early and Be Seated. Please, for the love of the theatrical gods, make every effort to arrive on time. Double-check the curtain time on your tickets, as showtimes can vary significantly depending on the day of the week. Avoid being that person who disrupts hundreds of fellow audience members, already engrossed in the performance, by attempting to find your seat three songs into the opening act. Broadway tickets are a considerable investment, and no one wants their view or their immersion to be compromised because you’re navigating the aisle. The simplest and most effective way to prevent this scenario is to arrive well in advance. Theater doors typically open 30 minutes before the stated curtain time, allowing ample opportunity to settle in. I found that even long lines outside the theater tend to move remarkably quickly once doors open.

2. Utilize Ushers for Seamless Navigation and Playbills. Upon entering the theater, allow the ticket-taker or an usher to guide you directly to your seats. This simple step will save you precious time and prevent unnecessary meandering around the unfamiliar layout of the theater. These dedicated ushers are true experts in their venues. Furthermore, if you wish to receive a Playbill – the cherished official program and souvenir – you’re much more likely to get one from an usher rather than attempting to seat yourself. A little patience goes a long way, and your Playbill will serve as a wonderful memento of your Broadway experience.

3. Practice Thoughtful Audience Etiquette. Self-awareness and consideration for those around you are incredibly underrated in today’s world, yet they are paramount in a shared theatrical space. Take off your bulky coat so it doesn’t obstruct the view or comfort of the person behind you. If you must have snacks, unwrap any crinkly packaging or open bags of chips or pork rinds *before* the show begins (or, even better, enjoy your food before you arrive). Most crucially, turn your cell phone completely off and put it away, out of sight. This eliminates the temptation to take unauthorized photos or glance at messages, which are highly distracting to both performers and fellow audience members. When I watch these incredible shows, I enter a complete trance, finding it easy to disconnect and fully immerse myself in the performance.

4. Embrace Silence During the Performance. This point is closely related to number three, but it’s so critical it deserves its own emphasis: do not talk during the show. During two of the four shows I attended that weekend, my husband and I had to contend with loud conversationalists right beside us. In both instances, one person was actively explaining the plot to their companion throughout the performance, preventing everyone nearby from fully experiencing the narrative unfold naturally. If you’re unfamiliar with a show’s storyline, it’s a far better idea to research it *before* you arrive, rather than treating the theater like your private living room. The individual next to me didn’t even attempt to whisper, making his commentary incredibly distracting. Please, do not compromise the enjoyment and immersion of others around you. Simply put: don’t talk during the show.

5. Dress to Impress: Elevate Your Attire. Broadway is a grand occasion, a truly special event that calls for a touch of elegance. While there’s no strict dress code, dressing nicely elevates the experience for everyone involved. Think of it as stepping back in time to an era when people truly dressed for the occasion. Avoid sloppy attire. It’s BROADWAY! It’s a BIG deal! Respect the artistry on stage and the tradition of the theater by presenting yourself appropriately. Enough said.

6. Master the Art of Discounted Tickets with TKTS. One of the most effective strategies for securing discounted tickets (often up to 50% off) to Broadway shows is by utilizing the renowned TKTS booth. There are three convenient locations across the New York area: the bustling Times Square, the scenic South Street Seaport, and the vibrant downtown Brooklyn. Lines at these booths move surprisingly fast, and a small service charge contributes to the Theater Development Fund, supporting the arts. We personally used the Times Square location when we spontaneously decided to catch Rock of Ages last minute. The Seaport and Brooklyn locations offer an added benefit, allowing you to purchase tickets for the following day’s Matinee performance. While newer, high-demand shows might not always be available, many productions have excellent ticket availability at these booths. TKTS also offers a highly useful app that provides live updates on available shows and discounts, which we found incredibly helpful during our trip.

Now that you’re armed with these insights and tips, go forth and experience the incredible world of Broadway! Whether you choose one of the shows I’ve enthusiastically recommended or opt for something that perfectly suits your individual taste, I am confident you will not be disappointed. Every Broadway show offers a unique and unforgettable journey, and I promise, you’ll be captivated.